Best Pizza in Sun Prairie, WI | Sugar River Pizza

For family-friendly pizza with tons of seating and consistent quality, Sugar River Pizza Company has become our go-to spot over the years.

Located at 1390 Cabela Drive at the very edge of Sun Prairie, this place delivers solid pizzas, excellent service, and an atmosphere where families can actually relax and enjoy their meal without feeling rushed or cramped.

We've tried many of the offerings over the years, and while there are fancier pizza places in Sun Prairie, for value, easy-to-find seating, and a family-friendly environment, it's hard to beat Sugar River.

Quick Facts

📍 Location: 1390 Cabela Dr, Sun Prairie, WI 53590

⏰ Hours: Sunday - Thursday 11AM - 9PM | Friday - Saturday 11AM - 10PM

💵 Price Range: $12-25 per pizza

🚗 Parking: Large lot with plenty of parking

📱 Website: https://www.sugarriverpizza.com/sun-prairie

☎️ Phone: (608) 478-5950

🌟 Best For: Families, large groups, outdoor patio dining, craft beer selection

First Impressions & Atmosphere

Sugar River Pizza Company is really great for families, and that's evident the moment you walk in. Tons of seating spread throughout the restaurant means you're not fighting for a table or feeling squeezed into a tight corner. The space is large without feeling cavernous, and the noise level stays manageable even when busy.

We visited on an absolutely perfect summer day and got a table on the patio under an umbrella. The outdoor seating overlooks a really nice view of the little pond and walking path to the south. It's the kind of setting that makes you want to linger over your meal, watching families stroll by on the path while enjoying your pizza and a cold drink.

The restaurant sits in the Prairie Lakes area, just down the road from the Hilton Garden Inn. Lot parking is plentiful, which is a huge plus when you're wrangling kids or meeting up with a larger group. We've never had trouble finding a spot, even during peak dinner hours.

The Food: What We've Ordered

Over the years, we've made our way through a good portion of Sugar River's menu. The pizzas are always solid. They're consistent, which matters when you're a regular. You know what you're getting, and that reliability is valuable for families.

The classic pizza offerings are good. A straightforward pepperoni or sausage pizza hits the spot when that's what you're craving. But the specialty pizzas are wonderful, and that's where Sugar River really shines.

My personal favorite is the Ricotta Be Kiddin' Me. This pizza delivers on flavor with a creamy ricotta base that sets it apart from your standard red sauce pies. The combination of cheeses and toppings creates something special without being overly complicated.

The kids have started venturing out into the specialty pizza world because of the BBQ Pulled Pork pizza. Getting kids to try something beyond pepperoni is always a win, and this pizza has converted them. The pulled pork is tender, the BBQ sauce adds a sweet and tangy element, and it's become their new request whenever we visit.

The portions are generous, and most pizzas are easily shared among a family. The crust strikes a good middle ground, neither too thin nor too thick, which seems to please everyone at the table.

What Makes Sugar River Pizza Special

In Sun Prairie's growing pizza scene, Sugar River Pizza Company has carved out its niche as the family-friendly option that delivers on all fronts. This isn't about artisanal thin crust or deep dish experiments. This is about consistent, quality pizza in an environment where families feel welcome and comfortable.

The extensive menu means there's something for everyone. Beyond the pizza selection, they offer appetizers, flatbreads, salads, pastas, and sandwiches. When you're dealing with different tastes and preferences in a group, that variety matters.

The craft beer selection is impressive, with 48 beers on tap according to recent counts. For parents looking to unwind with a good beer while the kids enjoy their pizza, Sugar River delivers. The full bar also offers craft cocktails and wines, making it a solid option for adults as well.

Service has been excellent and personable across our many visits. The staff is attentive without hovering, friendly with kids, and keeps things moving efficiently even when the restaurant is busy.

The Verdict: Is Sugar River Pizza Worth It?

Absolutely, especially for families. I think it's fair to say that there are fancier pizza places in Sun Prairie, especially if you prefer thinner crust or deep dish. But for family-friendly atmosphere, easy-to-find seating, consistent quality, and good value, it will be hard to beat a stop at Sugar River.

The specialty pizzas like the Ricotta Be Kiddin' Me and BBQ Pulled Pork are standouts, and that patio with the pond view on a perfect summer day is unbeatable.

Practical Tips for Your Visit

🅿️ Parking & Access: Large parking lot makes access easy for everyone, including families with strollers or larger groups.

⏱️ Best time to visit: Open seven days a week. Weekday evenings tend to be slightly quieter than weekends. The patio is seasonal, so take advantage during the warmer months.

💡 Insider tips: Try the specialty pizzas over the classics. The Ricotta Be Kiddin' Me is a must-try. If you're visiting in summer, request patio seating for that pond view. Check the board in the bar area for their rotating craft beer selection.

♿ Accessibility: Accessible with ample space for wheelchairs and strollers.

👥 Good for groups?: Absolutely. With tons of seating throughout the restaurant, this place was built for groups and families. Large parties are easily accommodated.

📶 Dining style: Full-service restaurant with table service. The atmosphere is casual and relaxed, perfect for lingering over pizza and drinks.

Final Thoughts

Sugar River Pizza Company has earned its spot as our reliable family pizza destination in Sun Prairie. Over the years, the pizzas have remained consistently solid, the specialty options like the Ricotta Be Kiddin' Me continue to impress, and the family-friendly atmosphere never disappoints.

The combination of tons of seating, excellent service, a beautiful patio with pond views, and a menu that offers something for everyone makes this place a winner for families and groups. While it may not be the fanciest pizza spot in Sun Prairie, it excels at what matters most: creating a comfortable environment where families can enjoy good pizza without stress.

If you're looking for a family-friendly pizza spot in Sun Prairie with reliable quality, generous portions, and space to actually relax, Sugar River Pizza Company on Cabela Drive is the answer. Grab a table on the patio, order the Ricotta Be Kiddin' Me, and enjoy the view. We'll see you there.

Have you been to Sugar River Pizza? Drop a comment below with your favorite specialty pizza or what I should try on my next visit!

Looking for more family-friendly restaurant reviews in the Madison area? Check out my complete dining guide.

I paid for this meal myself. All opinions are my own.

Last updated: November 2025

(Featured image photo by Horizon Content: https://www.pexels.com/photo/close-up-shot-of-a-pizza-3826016/)

If you found this article helpful please consider supporting Spots Travel Guide via the link above. Donations generated through the Buy Me a Coffee platform help bring recognition and support to the local businesses within our cities.